Should the elemrntary school students have their own cellphoness?

Moderater:Anna Janes
panelits:Amy Green, Alex Bell, Rie Chein, Kate Hail, Rachel Williams

Amy:agree
If children have their own cellphone, they can ask their help in emergency. But we should teach how to use cellphone correctly.

Alex:agree
Cellphone has GPS function and it is very useful. She has children and her children have their children.

Rie:disagree
Cellphone is not good for children's eyes. Also he think children should play outside without cellphone.

Kate:disagree
Children have a lot of things to do(study and sports and so on...). If children have cellphone, they should waste time by them.

Rachel:disagree
She worry about dangerous of Internet. Internet is too dangerous for children, so they shouldn't use them.

Alex:We are double-income family, so my children spend a lot of time without adults. If some disaster hapen, what should they do?
Rie:In emergency, it is difficult to use cellphone and people can help each other.

Sara:I think every family have different situations. It is natural that every family have different rules.

Sophie:Do you want to make a law? or rule?
Anna:We want to make a rule.

Conclusion
We should make a family rule depends on their family situations.

Final comment
I think it was strange that they tried to make a rule. They should understand their purpose or why they talk about their topic. But all panelists speak many times and the moderater was very good!